Archives

Comparisons Are Odious (but Fun)

Eric of Evangelical Underground is taking nominations beginning today through January 1 for the 2006 Evangelical Blog Awards. Go here to see the categories and last year’s winners.

Title note:

The earliest recorded use of this phrase appears to be by Sir John Fortescue, Chief Justice of the King’s Bench, in his 15th century work, De laudibus legum Angliæ. It was used by several authors later, notably Cervantes, Christopher Marlowe and John Donne.

In Much Ado About Nothing, Shakespeare gives Dogberry the line ‘comparisons as odorous’. It seems he was using this ironically, knowing it to be a misuse of what would have been a well known phrase by 1598/99 when the play was written.

From The Phrase Finder

How To Read a Book

Are you in the Blogger Limelight?

So now Ariel at Bittersweet Life is asking, “What Makes a Great Reader?” He cites the example of students who complain to him that they’re being forced to waste their valuable time on To Kill a Mockingbird and The Great Gatsby. The question becomes how can we teach these students, or how can we teach ourselves, to come away from worthwhile texts having learned or grown or thought deeply? How do we make ourselves or others into “great readers”?

Well, first of all, we keep assigning great books: old books, books that are esteemed, even new books, books that are, shudder, popular, books that someone else appreciates and tells us about. We assign ourselves to read whatever is pure and lovely and virtuous and praiseworthy and of good report. We make ourselves read the best literature we can find.

Then, we think–humbly. I posted this quote from A.A. Milne a long time ago, but it’s worth posting again in this context.

“One does not argue about The Wind in the Willows. The young man gives it to the girl with whom he is in love, and, if she does not like it, asks her to return his letters. The older man tries it on his nephew, and alters his will accordingly. The book is a test of character. We can’t criticize it, because it is criticizing us. But I must give you one word of warning. When you sit down to it, don’t be so ridiculous as to suppose that you are sitting in judgment on my taste, or on the art of Kenneth Grahame. You are merely sitting in judgment on yourself. You may be worthy: I don’t know, But it is you who are on trial.”

Isn’t this true of any great book? One way to become a great reader is to remember who you are. You are the most recent in a long line of readers to come to Dickens or Tolstoy or Homer or even Harper Lee and sit at their feet and be judged worthy of learning what they have to teach–or unworthy. There are many classic authors that I am not yet a good enough reader to appreciate, but humility tells me that the flaw is in my understanding, not in the author’s work. Not that any author’s work achieves god-like perfection, but if millions have learned something from a given piece of literature and I receive nothing, perhaps I need to work a little harder. Yes, in some few cases, especially in the case of more modern literature that has not yet been judged by many generations of great readers, the emperor may have no clothes, but generally if lots of discerning readers over a long period of time say that Author X has something to give, he probably does. And I become a great reader by applying my brain to the problem of finding that something, maybe even writing about it, asking questions, thinking.

It all comes back to humility. Wasn’t that what Mr. Vanderhorst’s last question was about?

Call Me Ishmael

On November 14, 1851, Herman Melville’s novel Moby Dick was first published in the U.S.

I must admit that I never finished Moby DIck. Well, I finished it, read the end, but I skipped a lot in the middle. The chapter called “The Whiteness of the Whale” just didn’t do much for me–an entire chapter on whiteness. I’m sure I missed something very important and enlightening there, but I just couldn’t manage it.

Have any of you read Moby Dick? Can anyone tell me why you like it if you do?

Nature Never Stops Talking by Samuel J. Alibrando

Subtitled “The Wonderful Ingenuity of Nature,” this book is right down Engineer Husband’s alley. The author, Samuel Alibrando, has been “writing articles about nature for 10 years in a small local paper for foothill residents in central California.” Engineer Husband also enjoys doing things to get people, especially kids, excited about science. So Mr. Alibrando and Engineer Husband have a lot in common. I, on the other hand, am not a science person at all. But Nature Never Stops Talking gave me some new thoughts about science, philosophy, and common sense that were well worth the time spent reading.

The book itself is a compilation of some of Mr. Alibrando’s columns with bridge material and extra information added to flesh the book out–not filler, mind you, but rather Alibrando’s Laws, and Ripples and examples of how those laws and ripple effects work out in real life. The book is divided into sections: Earth and Space, Scientific Properties, The Small Stuff, Beginnings, Plants and Trees, Insects, Specific Creatures, DNA, and The Human Body. The final section is called “Yeah, What About That” and has to do with a hodgepodge of ideas concerning evolution, design, nature, population and . . . . well, a conglomeration of other stuff. So here’s a sampling of the new-to-me ideas that I got from reading Nature Never Stops Talking:

1) Alibrando’s Law #1: To exist, a thing must first begin, specifically. And for living things that reproduce sexually, there had to be two firsts, a male and a female, at the same time and in the same place. Think about it. One squirrel can’t reproduce squirrels by itself; there had to be two squirrels, one male and one female, in the same place at the same time with the same number of chromosomes to make more squirrels. So how do evolutionists get that particular miracle to happen?

2) The more complicated a design, the more brains it takes to put it together. So can anyone reading these words create, ex nihilo, out of nothing, a tree or a raccoon, or even an amoeba? Can you even put one together if I give you the raw materials?

3) If a population doubles within a generation, or about every 40 years, then calculating backwards to 0, it would take about 1500 years for the population of humans to get from where it is now to 0 –or 2. Throw in plagues and wars and whatever else you can think of, and you still don’t get few enough people and limited enough reproduction to fill millions–or very many thousands– of years. So what happened?

So if you’re interested in these kinds of questions and this kind of common sense thinking, you should dip into Samuel Alibrando’s Nature Never Stops Talking. You might find yourself asking a few more questions and thinking a few more wonder-filled thoughts. I’m planning to read it out loud to the urchins at the supper table.

This book was given to me as a gift by Mind and Media for the purpose of review. You can purchase a copy of Nature Never Stops Talking: The Wonderful Ingenuity of Nature by Samuel Alibrando from any of these bookstores.

What They’re Reading

George Grant is reading biographies of Shakespeare and Augustine, and he’s reading Jan Karon and a thriller by Vince Flynn. And I thought I was eclectic.

Dani at A Work in Progress is reading So Many Books, So Little Time by Sara Nelson. I read this book about a year ago, and although Ms. Nelson and I don’t have the same taste in books, I thoroughly enjoyed her zest for reading and her adventures in reading one book per week for a year.

Javamom is reading American literature and planning to read Dostoyevsky–someday. I will agree that one must PLAN to read Dostoyevsky–make a date, so to speak. It’ll be worth the effort.

And M-MV has her twenty-fourth installment of “On the nightstand (under the pillow, in the knapsack, etc.)” here.

So now you know what some of THEM are reading. What are you reading this fine Saturday?

To This Great Stage of Fools: Born November 11th

He was born on this date in 1821.

While he was at school, his father was murdered by his own servants at the family’s small country estate.

He graduated from engineering school but chose a literary career.

He was arrested and charged with subversion because of his meetings with a group of intellectuals to discuss politics and literature. He and several of his associates were imprisoned and sentenced to death. As they were facing the firing squad, an imperial messenger arrived with the announcement that the death sentences had been commuted to four years in prison and four years of military service..

While in prison, his intense study of the New Testament, the only book the prisoners were allowed to read, contributed to his rejection of his earlier liberal political views and led him to the conviction that redemption is possible only through suffering and faith.

In 1867, he fled to Europe with his second wife to escape creditors.

He returned home and finished what many consider to be his greatest novel two months before his death in 1881

Quotes by Mr. X:

“Man only likes to count his troubles, but he does not count his joys.”
“It’s life that matters, nothing but life–the process of discovering, the everlasting and perpetual process, not the discovery itself at all.”
“So long as man remains free he strives for nothing so incessantly and so painfully as to find some one to worship.”
“If there is no God, then I am God.”
“Taking a new step, uttering a new word is what people fear most.”

Quotes about Mr. X:

“…the only psychologist from whom I have anything to learn.” – Nietzsche
“. . . gives me more than any scientist, more than Gauss.” – Albert Einstein
“an author whose Christian sympathy is ordinarily devoted to human misery, sin, vice, the depths of lust and crime, rather than to nobility of body and soul” -Thomas Mann
“..the nastiest Christian I’ve ever met”.-Turgenev
“He was in the rank in which we set Dante, Shakespeare and Goethe.” – Edwin Muir
“My husband was to me such an interesting and wholly enigmatic being, that it seemed to me as though I should find it easier to understand him if I noted down his every thought and expression.” -Mr X’s second wife
(My response to Mrs. X’s observation is: aren’t they all? But who would have time or energy to write it all down–and then try to figure it out?)

Box of Books blogger, Ella, says this author’s name should be used as a noun meaning “something or someone who excites feelings of deep sadness”. She adds, “You’d think . . . our gloomy friend would be at least semi-popular.”

Finally, I never have been able to decide how to spell his name. So who is it? And what about you? Have you read his novels? What did you think? Do you find him gloomy and sad or interesting and enigmatic–or all of the preceeding? And how do you spell his name?

Going on a Book Hunt

Jacob Weisberg of Slate goes Bookhunting in Britain., and he describes his two favorite bookstores in London.

Unfortunately, I don’t have a favorite London bookstore. My favorite bookstores here in Houston are Half-Price Books and Barnes and Noble. If Half-Price put in some couches and tables, I’d probably desert Barnes and Noble, but B & N is a nice place to browse the latest and theoretically greatest.

What’s your favorite bookstore? Why?

Picture Book Preschool

WEEK 46 (Nov) PETS
Character Trait: Dependability
Bible Verse: The Lord God took the man and put him in the Garden of Eden to work it and take care of it. Genesis 2:15

1. Day, Alexandra. Good Dog, Carl. Green Tiger, 1985.
2. 2. Anderson, C.W. Billy and Blaze. Macmillan, 1969.
3. Selsam, Millicent. Let’s Get Turtles. Harper Row, 1965. OP
4. Gag, Wanda. Millions of Cats. Coward, 1928.
5. Yashima, Mitsu and Taro. Momo’s Kitten. Viking, 1961.
6. Brown, Margaret Wise. Baby Animals. Illustrated by Susan Jeffers. Random House, 1989.
7. Newberry, Clare T. Marshmallow. Smithmark, 1999.
BONUS: Bridwell, Norman. Clifford, the Big Red Dog. Scholastic, 1963.

Activities: Involve your child in caring for the family pet, if you have one and if he is not already doing so. Talk about how God gave people the job of caring for the animals.
Visit a pet store.

Picture Book Preschool is a preschool/kindergarten curriculum which consists of a list of picture books to read aloud for each week of the year and a character trait, a memory verse, and activities, all tied to the theme for the week. You can purchase a downloadable version (pdf file) of Picture Book Preschool by Sherry Early at Biblioguides.

Booklist Round-Up

Inspired (or infuriated) by TIME Magazine’s publication in October of its 100 Best English-language novels from 1923 to the present, several bloggers have been busily making their own lists. Enjoy.

Ella at Box of Books: Fifty Favorites

Phil at Brandywine Books: List of Books, Stories and Plays I Remember Enjoying

Joe Carter at Evangelical Outpost: 50 Favorite Works of Imaginative Literature (20th Century)

Cindy Swan at Notes in the Key of Life: My Top Twenty-five Books of All Time

Dianne at Unfinished Work: Top Twenty-five Book List

Ariel at Bittersweet Life: The Master Book List

Mark Mossa at You Duped Me Lord: Great Novels

Danielle at A Work in Progress: My List of Thumping Good Reads

So Many Books: A List of Great Reads

Jared at Mysterium Tremendum: Fave Fifty

If you have such a list at your blog, leave a comment and I’ll add you to this list, a list of lists.