Archives

Seven Quick Takes Friday

I thought I’d write my Seven Quick Takes on seven of Cybils nominees that I read, but didn’t get around to reviewing:
1) Aloha Crossing by Pamela Bauer Mueller. This one is a sequel to Hello, Goodbye, I Love You: The Story of Aloha, A Guide Dog for the Blind by the same author. I didn’t much care for the further adventures of Aloha the guide dog and his owner Kimberly, but others really did.


2) Up and Down the Scratchy Mountains by Laurel Snyder. Lucy the milkmaid and Wynston the prince are best friends even if their favorite thing to do is argue with each other. But now Wynston’s father King Desmond says he must find a princess to marry, and Lucy longs to know what exactly happened to her mother who disappeared many years ago when Lucy was only a baby. So lonely with out her best friend, Lucy decides to go on an adventure all by herself up the Scratchy Mountains. I’m reading this one out loud to Z-baby.
Miss Erin interviews Laurel Snyder about this book.

3) Breathing Soccer by Debbie Spring. Too agenda driven for me, but if your child or friend deals with the issue of playing sports while coping with asthma, you might want to check out this story of Lisa, who rises above her physical challenges to play soccer in spite of the nay-sayers and fear-mongers in her life.


4) Lizard Love by Wendy Townsend. Grace really, really likes reptiles: snakes, iguanas, lizards, etc. When she happens into the store Fang & Claw and meets Wlater who likes reptiles as much as she does, she feels as if she’s found a home away from home in spite of her difficulties fitting in anywhere else. I liked this book even though I’m not a reptile fan. Discussions of reptilian sex and puberty and body image, although tastefully done, limit the audience for this book to adolescent girls and older.

5) Meeting Miss 405 by Lois Peterson. Dad says that while Tansy’s mom is away from home Tansy has to stay after school with boring old Miss Stella from Apartment 405—even though Tansy thinks she’s old enough to take care of herself and doesn’t need a babysitter. It’s not easy, but Tansy learns some things from Miss Stella, including how to become “super-concentrated” and what to do about missing her mother so much. The themes here are families dealing with mental illness and tolerance for others. Kim on Meeting Miss 405.


6) Anna Smudge: Professional Shrink by MAC. Comic-bookish storyline without the pictures. The book starts out with Anna in jail and then goes back in time to tell how she got there. It’s Anna and her friends against Mr. Who, the criminal mastermind, but who exactly is Mr. Who? And can a girl whose only talent is a gift for counseling really save New York CIty from Mr. Who’s dastardly machinations? I thought it was sort of silly, but Kim loved it and Melissa liked it, too. And Karate Kid who is the expert on what eleven year old boys will read liked it, too.


7) The Big Splash by Jack Ferraiolo. Either this one or The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey was Karate Kid’s favorite of all the Cybils nominees he read; he can’t decide. Adults will find The Big Splash rather, well, juvenile, with potty humor, and really cruel kids. It’s a hard-boiled noir detective novel for junior high kids. If you like Dashiell Hammett or Raymond Chandler and can still channel your middle school self, or if you’re still in middle school, you might want to check it out. But even for fifty year old moms, it has its moments. The relationship between protagonist Matt and his single mom is beautiful and spot-on. See Presenting Lenore for a full review and and interview with the author.

Christmas in South Dakota, 1910

She unwrapped an unwieldy bundle, covered with newspapers. Out of it fell a giant tumble weed, its spiny leaves dried on its skeleton stalk; its bushy top mounted on a trunk made of a broomstick. “Do you think that would do fer a Christmas tree?” she asked.

Becky looked at the dry bush with softened eyes.

“I thought maybe I could use some plum brush fer a tree, went on the child. “But I just hate the switchey look of’em for Christmas. So when this whopper tumble weed came along last fall it stuck in our chicken wire, and I hung it up in the barn. It dried just that way, and I thought maybe the children would like it fer a tree. The little ones never seen no pictures of one, even, and they wouldn’t know if it wasn’t just like. I got a pail of sand to stick that broomstick down in. I could hang the popcorn and the light strings on the tumble weed, and put the rest around it. Do you think that would work, Miss Linville?”

“I’m sure the children would love it.”

~The Jumping Off Place by Marian Hurd McNeely

Last night and today I have been enjoying this story, first published in 1929 and republished this year by the South Dakota State Historical Press for a new generation of readers. (The cover pictured here is from the older edition since the new paperback cover is not available at Amazon.) Little House on the Prairie fans who have exhausted Ms. WIlder’s canon and all its spin-offs, should try this story of a family of four orphan children who take up a homestead in South Dakota, determined to hold down their claim for fourteen months until they can gain title to the 160 acres of South Dakota farm left to them by their beloved Uncle Jim. Uncle Jim’s death at the beginning of the story gives the children a grief that is slow to heal, but the words and plans that he left them guide them in their new life on the prairie.

The Jumping-Off Place was a Newbery Honor book in 1930. (Laura Ingalls WIlder didn’t win her first of four Newbery Honors until 1938.) It’s a wonderful story of pioneering on the Great Plains in the early part of the twentieth century. Only one caveat: one of the characters does use the phrase “ni— work” to refer to the hard work of making a life on the prairie, a phrase I’m sure was common usage in that time and place, but offensive to modern ears nevertheless.

The book is for a bit more mature readers than those who first come to the Little House books. Ms. McNeely doesn’t sugarcoat the drudgery and suffering that those who settled the Great Plains had to endure. In one scene a baby dies of snakebite in a poverty-stricken dugout home, and fifteen year old Becky, the oldest of the four children, helps to lay out the body of the little girl and prepare it for burial. Some of the settlers are kind and helpful to the children, while others are mean and ornery. I think older children (ages 11-14 or so) who like this sort of tale will read anxiously to see if and how the children hold their claim and become part of the new Dakota society.

Other read-alikes in the pioneering children and young adults genre:

Hattie Big Sky by Kirby Larson. Another Newbery Honor book, reviewed here at Maw Books Blog.

By Crumbs It’s Mine by Patricia Beatty.

My Face to the Wind: The Diary of Sarah Jane Price, A Prairie Teacher. Broken Bow, Nebraska, 1881 by Jim Murphy

West to a Land of Plenty: The Diary of Teresa Angelino Viscardi, New York to Idaho Territory, 1883 by Jim Murphy.

Any other suggestions?

Interview with Author Andrea White

Andrea White is the author of three books for young people: Surviving Antarctica, Radiant Girl, and Window Boy. She’s also involved in community efforts to keep kids in school until they graduate, and she’s married to Mayor Bill White of Houston, Texas, which happens to be my home also. I emailed her these interview questions, and she very kindly took the time to answer. Enjoy.

Eldest Daughter says every good interview begins with the question: what did you have for breakfast? I like to humor her, so what is your breakfast of choice?
I never had pomegranates until five years or so ago and now I love them. I heap a spoon of pomegranates on cereal from the bins at Whole Foods.

I think it’s fascinating and kind of cool that the mayor of my city is married to a writer of children’s books. How did you get started writing children’s fiction? And the perennial question, why do you write for children and young adults rather than adults?
I wrote three novels for adults, never published, but found I was better at writing for kids. I’m only an average prose stylist but I have a better than average imagination. Besides, I love going to schools and talking to kids.

I’ve read and enjoyed all three of your published books, Surviving Antartica, Window Boy, and Radiant Girl. They all have such different settings: a future dystopia mostly in Antarctica, the life of a boy with cerebral palsy in the late 1960’s, and finally Chernobyl in 1986. What led you to these widely different times and places? Didn’t it take an enormous amount of research to get each setting right?
The truth is–you never know where you ideas will come from. When I talk to kids, I always remind them that ideas can start really small. Ideas don’t necessarily come in fancy, wrapped packages. Nor are they accompanied by a fireworks display. They can be just a flash of insight that will lead you to interesting places you’ve never even dreamed of. The idea for Surviving Antarctica took root after I read, The Worst Journey in the World, by Aspley Cherry Garrard. He was a surviving member of the Robert Scott expedition. I grew fascinated by the Scott’s team attempt to be the first to reach the South Pole. When you write a book for children or adolescents, they have to be at the center of the action; and in a sane world, parents would never let their kids go to Antarctica alone. That’s when I decided to make up a new world. In 2083, public schools have closed. Kids watch school on television. History is taught through Survivor, Math through Dialing for Dollars and English through Tela Novelas. There are two moons in the sky, the natural moon and one that advertisers installed.
I got the idea for Radiant Girl, my most recent book about the Chernobyl disaster, from a photograph I saw on the Internet. The photo showed a girl on a motorcycle in the Dead Zone–where towns and families once flourished–and when I saw that picture of the girl I knew I wanted to write about Chernobyl. The inscription was, “As I pass through the checkpoint into the Dead Zone, I feel like I have entered an unreal world. It is divinely eerie like the Salvador Dali painting of the dripping clocks.”
With Window Boy, I was reading a biography of Winston Churchill by William Manchester. There was one sentence in the book that caught my attention. It said–Churchill had no problem standing up to Hitler, because as a child he fought the hardest enemy anyone ever has to beat–the despair that comes from being an unloved child. I decided in that moment that I wanted to write a book about Churchill. I didn’t have a plot, but I also knew I wanted to write about basketball because my son loves basketball and I wanted him to read my book. Then, one afternoon I picked up a New York Times Magazine and on the cover was a picture of a boy in a wheelchair. When I saw him, I knew I wanted him to be my main character. I had my plot when I asked myself what would happen if a boy in a wheelchair wanted to play basketball. If a boy like that had a dream that big, he could use an imaginary friend like Winston Churchill.

Your books are educational without being didactic. I think, having read some books lately that are oppressively educational, that education in a story is a hard balance to pull off. Do you think about that balance as you write? How do you keep the story the main thing?

I take it as a personal challenge to help middle-schoolers learn about big subjects like Chernobyl and Winston Churchchill. And to do that you have to make history come alive for them. A nuclear explosion would not be something that a teenager would be thinking about unless you mix some fantasy in with it. In the Ukraine, folk tales abounded. One story was about the domovky, or house elf, and I asked myself what would happen if the domovky warned the girl about the explosion.
As to research, I love it and want to tell the story as accurately as possible. And, that was not easy with Radiant Girl. When the explosion happened, Ukraine was part of the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union was not a transparent society, and even with an independent Ukraine, information about this catastrophic event is inconsistent and murky.
So I felt it was very important to go and see it for myself. I went to Chernobyl and met a wonderful guide named Rimma. Although no one is allowed to live in the Dead Zone, some people work there two weeks on and two weeks off, and tourists can visit with special permission. Rimma showed me many places. We went to the ghost town of Pripyat. We entered empty schools with lessons still on the blackboard and graded papers scattered on the ground.
She took me to that bright yellow Ferris wheel in Pripyat, a city near Chernobyl; it never had a chance to turn. Since my character, Katya, climbed this yellow Ferris wheel–so did I. (Or almost.) Let me tell you, never in my wildest dreams would I have believed that I would climb a Ferris wheel in Pripyat, Ukraine.
When I got back to Houston, I had a million more questions and I emailed Rimma, but I didn’t hear back. I made some inquiries and after several months found out that she had died of a stroke. She was a healthy-looking 46-year old. I don’t know and will never know if her death was related to the higher levels of radiation caused by the explosion; she was in and out of the Dead Zone regularly since it happened. Although my encounter with her was brief, I won’t forget her or her friendship.
I continued my research, but still had many questions about the Ukraine. Everything from–what first names should I use for my characters? What kind of cars did they drive in 1986 when the explosion occurred? How would my fictional family, Ukrainians who lived in a small village, celebrate Katya’s birthday? There were so many details I had to get right.
I was at a cocktail party one evening in Houston and ran into someone I knew; he had with him a woman with a lovely accent. I asked her here she was from—and yes, she was from the Ukraine.
Tetyana is a brilliant woman who is studying to become a doctor. She was a young girl living in Kiev at the time of Chernobyl. She remembered that day well. She said she still doesn’t understand it from a scientific standpoint, but on that day, the streets of Kiev went absolutely quiet. Even the leaves drooped.
Katya Radiant Girl
Her father was an employee of a government agency like FEMA, and he instructed her mother and her to leave Kiev and go to the countryside. Her father had to return to the Dead Zone, and just like Katya’s father he died of thyroid cancer from exposure to radiation. Radiant Girl is dedicated to Tetyana’s father and the thousands of others like him.
This is the picture that Tatiana drew of Katya.

And, of course, what can we expect to see next from Andrea White? (Whatever it is, I’m looking forward to it. I’ve become a fan.)
I try to write every day. My current book is called Time Cops. It’s about an academy where kids learn to time travel. Here’s the opening paragraph:

“The Zone, an invisible structure, rose several hundred feet above the Lower D.C. slum. Were you to strip the cloaking paint from the building it would appear as a series of spoked wheels, one atop the other. The base, constrained by a gray xiathium fence, widened above the fence line, then narrowed again to a tower that rose to a sharp peak topped by a sphere. External stairwells and crenellated walks linked each storey; the whole edifice resembling a medieval castle made of machine parts. A stranger, on seeing it, might think he had found the inner engine of a monumental watch ticking silently in the midst of squalor.
Of course, no one can see time itself. No more than any stranger could see the Zone. Anymore than he or anyone else could view what went on inside that monumental watch. A watch made up of Chronos operatives—the moving parts of the machinery. The guardians of Time. Monks. Fanatics. Worshippers. But they prefer Time cops or just plain cops. They’re on the job. For you. For me. For our children. Our children’s children. Through the centuries.”

Read more about Andrea White and her books at her website, Andrea White, Author.

Semicolon review of Window Boy by Andrea White.

Review of Radiant Girl by Melissa at Book Nut.

Review of Surviving Antarctica by Melanie at The Indextrious Reader.

Christmas in Rome, AD 800

As the crown settled on his head, as the Pope stepped back and raised his hand in blessing, Charles closed his eyes and folded his hands. He stayed thus for perhaps a minute; then he rose.

Instantly a mighty shout burst forth: “Long life and victory to Charles, the most pious Augustus, by God Crowned the great and pacific Emperor of the Romans!”

Over and over again the shouts rang to the roof, echoing and beating against the walls, against the columns and the arches, making the candles flicker and flare with the breath of so many voices. The cry was handed back by those pressed in the doorway, carried back and out into the space beyond, so that it seemed all Rome at that moment rang with acclamation.

Was this not all that he could have wished for from the people?

He turned and faced them all. At once they were still. They gazed toward him eagerly.

When the silence was absolute, he spoke.

“I, Charles, Emperor—engage and promise in the name of Christ, in the presence of God and St. Peter the Apostle, to protect and defend the Holy Roman Church in all things profitable to the same, and, God being my helper, to the best of my knowledge and ability.”

~Son of Charlemagne by Barbara Willard.

Children’s Fiction of 2008: The Case of the Bizarre Bouquets by Nancy Springer

The scene opens in the first chapter of this Victorian mystery on a man mistakenly confined in a London insane asylum. The man claims to be Dr. John Watson, but no one believes him. One of my children tells me that insane asylums, or mental hospitals as they are called nowadays, are his greatest fear. I think this book would scare him silly —even though it’s perfectly appropriate for the middle school audience to whom it is directed.

As I read further, I realized that The Case of the Bizarre Bouquets was a Sherlock Holmes take off.This book is the third in the Enola Holmes series of Victorian mysteries by author Nancy Springer. I’m quite tempted to look for the first two in the series, The Case of the Missing Marquess and The Case of the Left-handed Lady, and recommend them to Brown Bear Daughter.

Enola, the eponymous heroine of the mystery, is the much younger sister of Mycroft and Sherlock, and as the story progresses we find that she is in hiding from her officious brothers who want to educate her and make her marriageable. Enola is not interested in marriage. Her ambition is to be the world’s first and only real private consulting Scientific Perditorian. (I don’t know what a perditorian is either. Perhaps it is explained in the first two books in the series —in which, I gather, Enola disguises herself as a secretary to a fake scientific perditorian?) At any rate, she has an old friendship with Dr. Watson, and when he turns up missing, Enola is determined to find out what has happened to him in spite of her need to hide from her meddling older brothers.

Sherlock Holmes fans should eat this up, and other mystery fans, especially girls who want an intrepid female detective with whom to identify, should find it fun and satisfying, too. I had a friend, W., back in junior high who would have called herself Enola and taken up writing fan fiction if this series had been available back then. W. was quite the Sherlock Holmes fan. In fact, I’m wondering if my friend, whom I haven’t heard from in a while, could have married and changed her first name to Nancy.

Nah. . . but it would make a good story for the next installment in The Enola Holmes Mysteries. Enola disguises herself as Nancy so that she can write and publish accounts of her adventures without hindrance from Victorian male family members who think she ought to marry and act like a lady.

Fiction/Nonfiction Pairs for More Book-giving to Kids

Sandy’s Circus: A Story About Alexander Calder by Tanya Lee Stone, illustrated by Boris Kulikov.
The Calder Game by Blue Balliet. Semicolon review here.

The Trouble Begins at 8: A Life of Mark Twain in the Wild, Wild West by Sid Fleischman.
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer by Mark Twain.

Helen’s Eyes: A Photobiography of Annie Sullivan, Helen Keller’s Teacher by Maria Ferguson Delano.
Miss Spitfire by Sarah Miller. Semicolon review here.

The Road to Oz: Twists, Turns, Bumps, and Triumphs in the Life of L. Frank Baum by Kathleen Krull.
The Wizard of Oz by L. Frank Baum.

In Defiance of Hitler: The Secret Mission of Varian Fry by Carla Killough McClafferty. Reviewed here by Laura Salas.
The Boy Who Dared by Susan Campbell Bartoletti. Semicolon review here.

Our White House: Looking In, Looking Out, a compilation by various authors. Reviewed here at a Patchwork of Books.
First Daughter: White House Rules by Mitali Perkins. Semicolon review here.

Snow Falling in Spring: Coming of Age in China During the Cultural Revolution by Moying Li. Reviewed here by Jennie at Biblio File.
Little Leap Forward: A Boy in Beijing by Guo Yue. Reviewed by Melissa at Book Nut.

The Kid’s Book of the Night Sky
Every Soul a Star by Wendy Mass. Reviewed by Melissa at Book Nut.
(I stole this idea from Mother Reader who has a great list of Twenty-one More Ways to Give a Book.)

Mighty Jackie the Strike-Out Queen by Marissa Moss. Reviewed here by Lori Calabreese.
No Cream Puffs by Karen Day. Reviewed by Melissa at Book Nut.

Sawdust and Spangles: The Amazing Life of W.C. Coup by Ralph Covert and G. Riley Mills. Reviewed here by Lori Calabrese.
The Floating Circus by Tracie Vaughn Zimmer. Semicolon review here.

Lincoln Shot: A President’s Life Remembered by Barry Denenberg, illustrated by Christopher Bing.
An Acquaintance with Darkness by Ann Rinaldi.

The Day the World Exploded: The Earthshaking Catastrophe at Krakatoa by Simon Winchester. Recommended by Kathryn Krull at I.N.K., Interesting Nonfiction for Kids.
The Twenty-One Balloons by William Pene du Bois.

How Does the Show Go On: An Introduction to the Theater by Thomas Schumacher.
The Diamond of Drury Lane by Julia Golding.

So You Want Women to Vote, Lizzie Stanton? by Jean Fritz.
The Hope Chest by Karen Schwabach.

Winston Churchill: Soldier and Politician by Tristan Boyer Binns.
Window Boy by Andrea White. Semicolon review here.

The Story of Baseball: Third Revised and Expanded Edition by Lawrence S. Ritter.
Keeping Score by Linda Sue Park. Semicolon review here.

How To Be a Samurai Warrior by Fiona Macdonald.
Sisters of the Sword by Maya Snow. Semicolon review here.

Knight (DK Eyewitness Books) by Christopher Gravett.
The Youngest Templar: Keeper of the Grail by Michael Spradlin.

Christmas in the North of England, 2007

“Tonight is the school Nativity play performed by Class 1 with an awful lot of help from the rest of the world because Class 1 can do nothing unaided. Mary and Joseph are the worst of the lot. If the real Mary and Joseph were anything like our Mary and Joseph there would be no Christmas because Christianity would have got no further than a big fight over who got the donkey somewhere along the road to Bethlehem.”

And afterwards:

“Buttercup was a perfect Baby Jesus. . . I think he may grow up to be a very talented actor because although it was quite a simple thing he had to do, just lie nicely on some hay, he managed it very well indeed. Class 1 had just as simple things to do, but they didn’t manage them half as well. The Wise Men had to be asked in front of everyone to settle down and leave the presents alone. And we will need a new donkey next year. With stronger ears.”

~Forever Rose by Hilary McKay.

Children’s Fiction of 2008: The Diamond of Drury Lane by Julia Golding

At the Theatre Royal in Drury Lane,
Covent Garden, this present day, being 1st January, 1790,

Will be presented

The Diamond of Drury Lane
(written by Miss Cat Royal)

Principal Characters
Miss Cat Royal–orphan and ward of the theater
Mr. Johnny Smith–prompter with a secret
Mr. Syd Fletcher–leader of the Butcher’s Boys and champion boxer
Mr. Billy “Boil” Shepherd–evil leader of rival gang

And a HIDDEN diamond!

With a new musical interlude by
Mr. Pedro Hawkins, late of Africa.

To which will be added a farce, in which
A HOT AIR BALLOON will land onstage!



I copied the blurb from the back cover of the book because the teaser was just as much fun as the writing in the story inside the book. Catherine Royal is an foundling of unknown parentage who lives backstage in Mr. Sheridan’s theater. She becomes involved in a plot to guard a hidden diamond as she overhears gossip that she’s not supposed to hear.

The book gives a great picture of the 1790’s for children, including cameo appearances by important personages, a look at the political issues of the time, and a vivid depiction of the cultural milieu of both the back alleys and the drawing rooms of late eighteenth century London. But history and cultural improvement were not the point of the story—the play’s the thing, as another author immersed in the theater would say. Cat would be a new and winsome addition to Jen’s Cool Girls of Children’s Literature list, and her friends and enemies in Drury Lane are a delight to get to know.

Cat warns her readers in the beginning of the book that “a different deportment is required on the streets of London than is usually taught to young ladies and gentlemen. . . . I hope you are not unduly shocked, for there is much more of the like to come.” I don’t think young readers will be unduly shocked by the violence and grit of 1790’s London as shown in The Diamond of Drury Lane, but they will be entertained and educated, both at the same time.

This book was published in 2006 in England where it won the Smarties Book Prize, a prize (similar to the Texas Bluebonnet Award) that was voted on by schoolchildren in Great Britain. It’s just now come out this year in the U.S., published by Roaring Brook Press. According to Ms. Golding’s website, there are already four more books in the Cat Royal series. The second one, Cat among the Pigeons, is available here in the U.S., and the third one is supposed to be “coming soon.”

More from other book bloggers:

Casey at Read a Great Teen Book: “Throughout all of her many adventures Cat stays true to her beliefs and her sense of right and wrong. Though Cat may be too trusting at times, she is crafty and intelligent and willing to risk everything to help a friend. The setting is richly portrayed and is accented by photographs of actual maps of London from 1790, the time when the story takes place.”

Sarah Rettger at Archimedes Forgets: “Makes me want to reread: Master Rosalind, by Patricia Beatty, another story of a girl in the theater with touches of political intrigue.”

I must add in response to Ms. Rettger that The Diamond of Drury Lane made me think of Sally Watson’s undervalued and almost forgotten classic about a girl in Shakespearean England, Mistress Malapert and the sort-of-sequel set during Cromwell’s reign, Lark. I love Patricia Beatty, so I’ll have to add Master Rosalind to my TBR list along with the others in the Cat Royal series.

Children’s Fiction of 2008: Surviving Seventh Grade

Fouling Out by Gregory Walters.

Carlos Is Gonna Get It by Kevin Emerson.

Bringing the Boy Home by N.A. Nelson.

Growing up is hard to do. That’s the message of all three of these middle grade fiction nominees, and the message comes through loud and clear. Craig in Fouling Out, Trina and her friends in Carlos Is Gonna Get It, and Tirio in Bringing the Boy Home all have to pass through their own rite of passage and come to some understanding that “coming of age” involves more than just celebrating a birthday. There’s some disillusionment and some hard facts of life to face at the end of each novel, but there’s also hope for the main character/narrator in each book and for the friend/helper whose problems impel each one to maturity.

Fouling Out, a Canadian title, begins with Craig Trilosky getting more than a little tired of his friend Tom. The boys have been friends since second grade, but Tom is becoming more and more wild and trouble-prone while Craig’s thinking he might make a lot fewer trips to the principal’s office and be more popular with the rest of the seventh grade class if he stopped hanging out with Tom so much. Changing your life and making new friends and loyalty to old friendships are a few of the themes of the book, and although Craig is low-class seventh grade —jaded, blase, and insecure underneath all the sarcasm and bravado—the thematic elements carried the story in spite of my antipathy for the narrator thoughout much of the book. I wanted Craig to lose the derisive and defiant voice, but I realized as I read that part of the message of the book was that change doesn’t come overnight, that growing up is a process, and that even underachieving and somewhat obnoxious seventh grade boys may have redeeming qualities.

I remembered that lesson as I read Carlos Is Gonna Get It by Kevin Emerson. I didn’t like the narrator of this one very much either at first. In fact, all through the book I just wanted to tell Trina to quit being so self-absorbed and get a life. She and her friends Thea, Sara, Donte, and Frankie, are, at the beginning of the story, absorbed in righting petty injustices with equally petty acts of retribution: call someone a hateful name, and Thea or one of the others will trip you at recess. Carlos (not a friend), however, is so weird and so disruptive and so annoying that his actions call for a plan that will stop his trouble-making once and for all. Trina thinks of herself as a “good girl” who just has to to get into trouble every once in a while. Her friends have equally well-drawn personalities, and the way the author used the events in the story to reveal his characters’ depths was one of my favorite aspects of the book. My most un-favorite aspect was the language: lots of OMG, God’s name used in vain as punctuation. The way the characters talked was also revealing, but I didn’t enjoy it at all. In fact I almost put the book down and quit, but the final scene got me. As Trina foresees/recounts the eighth grade futures of all the main characters in the book, the story becomes a poignantly bittersweet reflection on growing up and missed opportunities.

My favorite of these three seventh grade coming-of-age novels was N.A. Nelson’s Bringing the Boy Home. Tirio was cast out of the Takunami tribe at the age of six —by his own mother who placed him in a “corpse canoe” and sent him out into the current of the Amazon River. Tirio’s maimed foot made him a liability to the tribe, and he would never be able to pass the test of manhood. Rescued by an American anthropologist, Sara, Tirio goes to the United States, receives medical help for his foot, and grows up as normal soccer-playing American boy. But he doesn’t forget about his soche seche tente, his thirteen year old test of manhood, and now seven years after he left the Amazon, he’s being called back by the spirits, the good Gods, and by his father, the one who said he was too crippled to ever become a real man.

This story, although fictional, reminded me of so many things: first, the true story of Jim Elliot and Nate Saint who died in an attempt to bring the gospel to the isolated Auca/Waorani tribe in Amazonian Ecuador. Tirio’s Takunami tribe and its customs are made-up, but the author traveled in the Amazon jungle and incorporated what he learned there into his book. I was also struck by the parallels between Tirio’s fictional experience of clashing cultures, and the experience of a boy who is the adopted son of a close friend of mine. “Noah”, my friend, was born in Sierra Leone, and his arm was deliberately mangled in the fighting that has been going on there for some time. Christian missionaries brought “Noah” to the U.S. where he was able to receive medical care and a new family. (“Noah’s” parent’s died in Sierra Leone.) Like Tirio, “Noah” has been and continues to be challenged as he tries to integrate his cultural heritage and and his new family and American upbringing.

There’s no religious teaching of any kind, certainly not Christianity, in Tirio’s American experience. Tirio continues to believe in and depend upon “the good Gods” of his Takunami tribe with no conflicting messages from a Christian perspective. I think that’s a shame and a missed opportunity because it would be an interesting conflict to explore, but that’s not the book Mr. Nelson chose to write. And the book he did write is good enough, full of descriptive passages that made my mental picture of the Brazilian rain forest vivid and with plenty of action to satisfy the most adventurous of readers.

Bringing the Boy Home is highly recommended, and the other two books are worth reading and discussing if you can get past the narrator’s attitude in both and the casual profanity in Carlos.

A list of the Cybils Middle Grade Fiction nominees with links to panelists’ reviews of each book.

Semicolon reviews of Children’s and YA fiction of 2008, mostly Cybils nominees.

Children’s Fiction of 2008: Cybils Nominees Briefly Mentioned

10 Lucky Things That Have Happened to Me Since I Nearly Got Hit by Lightning by Mary Hershey. In this sequel to My Big Sister Is So Bossy She Says You Can’t Read This Book, ten year old Effie’s happy with her two best friends, Nit and Aurora, and her mom, the coach, and her bossy sister even though Effie’s dad is in prison for embezzlement. But when Aurora leaves their private school to go to public school, and when Mom’s friend, Father Frank moves in to get himself sorted out, and when bossy Maxey starts acting like a saint to impress the priest, Effie feels she must figure out how to straighten them all out and make everything return to way it used to be.

Longhorns and Outlaws by Linda Aksomitis. Twelve year old Lucas Vogel’s parents died in the Galveston Hurricane of 1900, and now his older brother Gil wants him to go with him to Montana and become a cowboy. But Lucas wants to go to school and eventually become a Pinkerton agent who chases down outlaws like Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. I’d recommend this one as a supplement to state history studies of Montana or of the turn of the century time period. Ms. Aksomitis has a website with free resources for teachers and links to free Old West movies. There’s a sequel in the works called Kidnapped by Outlaws.

A Thousand Never Evers by Shana Burg. In Kuckachoo, Mississippi, 1963, twelve year old Addie Ann Pickett sees injustice and the courage of those who fight against it as the Civil Rights movement begins to change life even in a small town in the Deep South.
Complete review at The Well Read Child.

Autumn Winifred Oliver Does Things Different by Kristin O’Donnell Tubb. Set on the edge of the Great Smoky Mountains during the Great Depression, this book is narrated by the eponymous Autumn who prides herself on doing things “different.” However, when she and her sister and her mama move in to Gramps cabin to take care of him instead of going to live with Pop in Knoxville, Autumn must deal with a great deal of “different” that she didn’t plan on at all.

Itch by Michele Kwasney. After the death of her beloved grandfather, Delores aka Itch moves with her grandmother from Florida to Ohio, under protest. She makes a new friend, Gwendolyn, but finds that the talented baton twirler has serious family problems (child abuse). Delores/Itch must learn to speak up and tell the truth even when it’s hard.
Full review from Bill at Literate Lives.

The Buddha’s Diamonds by Carolyn Marsden. A coming-of-age story set in present day Vietnam, this short book tells about Tinh and how he comes to understand his relationship to his father and his spiritual heritage of Buddhism.
Good review by cloudscome at a wrung sponge.

The Curse of Addy McMahon by Katie Davis. We’ve come full circle with a book in which a girl loses her best friend due to a misunderstanding, worries because her mother’s (boy)friend is moving in, and decides that she’s the victim of the McMahon family curse. Pair this one with 10 Lucky Things.
Cynsations interview with Katie Davis.

These are briefly mentioned because I’m reading furiously to complete as many of the 139 books on the Middle Grade fiction nominees list as I can before our panel must decide on the finalists. Stay tuned for more reviews and news about Cybils nominees.

A list of the Cybils Middle Grade Fiction nominees with links to panelists’ reviews of each book.

Semicolon reviews of Children’s and YA fiction of 2008, mostly Cybils nominees.