Why are people not up in arms about the new Consumer Products Safety Improvement Act? Why are the talk show hosts and the blogs and the news outlets not buzzing with information about this heinous law?
I think there are several reasons:
1) Even now that the law has gone into effect, many people are like I was —in denial. Our government could not be causing the wholesale destruction of books, children’s clothing, and toys for no discernible reason, could they? Either there must be a real danger OR it must not be happening.
Well, there is no danger to children from lead in books or clothing or toys. A very few pieces of jewelry may pose a problem, and even those are few and far between. SO no real danger.
And it is happening, folks, whether anyone wanted the books to be destroyed or not, they are being trashed. Scroll down to my previous post for more details.
2) Those who are in charge of enforcement in Washington and those who are responsible for passing this law in the first place don’t shop in used bookstores and in thrift stores. The national news media people do not shop in used bookstores and thrift stores. And many of them don’t have children. anyway. They do not see why the destruction of some old clothes and old books is such a problem. And they don’t listen to poor and middle class people who do shop in thrift stores and who do buy used books.
3) Publishers and new booksellers, who should be having a fit about CPSIA, don’t really want you to buy used books anyway. The used book market cuts into the sales of new books. So what if you can’t find a copy of Tasha Tudor’s pre-1985 books anymore? Just buy something new and shiny. Forget those old books.
4) Libraries have declared themselves exempt from CPSIA. Even though the libraries are loaning out the same books that used bookstores are being told to destroy or “sequester”, the libraries think they can go on their merry way unmolested because the ALA has told them that they can. Good luck with that. What happens when it comes time for the library book sale and your library wants to sell all those old books that it pulled from the shelves?
5) The news media is so busy trying to figure out and spin the stimulus bill that anything else is a distraction. CPSIA was a bill passed under a Republican administration (Bush) and now implemented under a Democratic one (Obama). Republicans and Democrats voted for CPSIA (all of them except for Ron Paul, I think). So, nobody gains any political points by realizing that the law was a mistake or by fixing it.
All of these reasons for inaction mean an uphill battle. I am sad that more and more books, irreplaceable copies of beautiful children’s books from the decades before 1985, are going to be destroyed because of a stupid, unnecessary law that never should have seen the light of day.
Call someone today before any more books are destroyed. And if you get a placating or patronizing answer, talk back. Be sassy. It’s time for some outrage. If you love freedom and books, please call to protest this book-banning law.





