Abandon Hope All Ye Who Enter Here

From an interview with Harold Bloom, author of The Closing of the American Mind and other (Thanks, Melissa) works of literary and cultural criticism:

IL: Do you have any relationship with God, be it intimate or not?

HB: A Christian has to believe that something is so, that Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God, a Muslim is asked to submit to the law of Yahwah – and the submision is the actual translation of the Arabic “Islam” – a Jew is not asked to believe that something is so and neither is he asked to submit to anything. He is asked to trust in the covenants between Yahwah and his people. Since it does not seem to me that Yahwah, historically speaking, has trusted in the covenant or observed the terms of the covenant – otherwise how could there have been Auschwitz? How could there be schizophrenia? How could there be cancer? – I do not accept. Oh, dear child, it is very complicated, I am in a difficult situation – I do not trust in the covenants, and I believe that Yahwah is in exile, that he has deserted us. On the other hand, the Kabbalah seems to me the truth. . . .

. . . my interests are far from what would be called religious, or rather I do not distinguish them from what I find in Shakespeare. So I find your question about my relationship with God almost imposible to answer. It’s like with that question about the Hamlet book: I feel that my consciousness breaks and I cannot get past a certain point. So I can just wave at you some quotes. For instance, if you, my dear, would cling to me in desperation and plead: “Is there really no hope at all?” I could cheer you up: Oh, yes, lots of hope – plenty of hope for God, just none for us.

He certainly is in a ” a very difficult situation.” And I don’t think “waving some quotes” is going to help him or anyone else. Say a prayer for Mr. Bloom; he sounds like a good man (in spite of his misguided political views).

2 thoughts on “Abandon Hope All Ye Who Enter Here

  1. Two different Blooms, both provocative: Allan Bloom (Closing of the American Mind) and Harold Bloom (Shakespeare: The Invention of the Human, Genius, and The Western Canon (to name a few of my favorites).

    We posted a link to this interview last week, as did Susan at Pages Turned. Funny how each of us pulled different quotes.

    Best regards.

    Melissa

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *