A Catholic Taste in Books

I’m Baptist born and bred, and by conviction, even though we are members of an Evangelical Free church now, but I’m not afraid of Catholicism or of talking about the differences between Catholics and Protestants with my children. Nor am I afraid of learning from my Catholic brothers and sisters in Christ. There’s something attractive and intriguing about Catholicism, especially as a motif and spiritual background in books. I know there other Catholic-flavored authors (ones I’ve never read) —Graham Greene, Evelyn Waugh, Flannery O’Connor, Walker Percy—but these are some of the books with a Catholic taste that I’ve read and enjoyed.

The Little World of Don Camillo by Giovanni Guareschi. I found this one a long time ago at a used bookstore. I’ve re-read it several times because it’s just fun. A little Catholic priest, Don Camillo, and a Communist mayor have a running feud in which they play out in comedic fashion the tensions and difficulties of post-WW II Italy. If you are offended at the idea of a priest praying before a crucifix and the Christ on the crucifix talking back to him, you won’t appreciate the humor in this book. However, I think it’s a delight.

Karen by Marie Killilea. This true story of a girl with cerebral palsy and her family was popular back in the 1960’s and 70’s. That’s when I first read it. This (Catholic) family is persistent, faithful and inspiring.

I just re-discovered In This House of Brede by Rumer Godden, an excellent story about the lives of women within a closed community of nuns. Not only does the reader get to satisfy his curiosity about how nuns live in a convent, but there’s also a a great plot related to contemporary issues such as abortion, the efficacy of prayer, and the morality of absolute obedience.

The Brother Cadfael mysteries by Ellis Peters take place in and around a 12th century monastery. This series of twenty medieval murder mysteries is perfect for those who like a taste of Catholicism mixed into their stories. G.K. Chesterton’s Father Brown mysteries feature a simple, unassuming, but quite insightful, priest who solves mysteries by applying his intelligence and powers of observation.

The Hawk and the Dove by Penelope Wilcock, along with the two other books in the trilogy, The Wounds of God and The Long Fall, is set in a medieval monastery and tells the stories of the monks who share in community there. Father Peregrine and the other monks are beautiful models of Christian love in community. I need to re-read these books. I’d recommend them for teenagers and adults.

I finally read A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter Miller this year. I thought it was excellent, but a bit quirky. A different kind of sci-fi.

Tolkien is, of course, very Catholic in an understated way. Especially in The Silmarillion I catch glimpses of a world in which there are Catholic-like hierarchies of beings. Instead of saints and angels interceding before the throne of God, we have the elves and the Numenoreans and the Valar and Maiar serving Iluvatar, the One True God.

Also, Victor Hugo’s Les Miserables and The Hunchback of Notre Dameare very Catholic, but also generically Christian in the best sense of the word. Jean Valjean, the hero of Les Miserables, may be my favorite character in all of literature. And he is saved by the witness and compassion of a Catholic bishop who serves God in humility.

For children:

Tomie DePaola writes beautiful books and illustrates them. Several of his books are about Catholic saints and stories: The Legend of the Poinsettia, The Clown of God, Patrick: Patron Saint of Ireland, Francis: The Poor Man of Assisi, The Lady of Guadalupe, and Mary: The Mother of Jesus. He also has written and published several Bible story books including The Miracles of Jesus, and The Parables of Jesus.

Pegeen by Hilda Van Stockumhas a Catholic setting because it’s set in Ireland, a very Catholic culture.

The Door in the Wall by Marguerite DeAngeli takes place for part of the book in a monastery, and Brother John is the wise mentor to a selfish boy as he learns to give to others instead of thinking always of himself.

Much historical fiction for children and adults has a Catholic flavor since it’s set in times when the culture was essentially Catholic. Read any book set in medieval Europe, and you should get a taste of what a Catholic culture looked and felt like. In fact, since Catholicism permeated that particular time and culture, if a work of fiction set in that time period does not have a distinctively Catholic taste, it’s probably not very historically accurate.

Added link: Joseph Bottum at First Things writes about another Catholic author, Morris West. has anyone read Shoes of the Fisherman or others of his books?

Do you have a Catholic taste in books, and if so, what are your favorites?

16 thoughts on “A Catholic Taste in Books

  1. Sherry,
    I have a great deal of appreciation for Catholic history and tradition. I learned about the Cadfael books last year, devoured them asap, and loved them. A friend recently put me on to Peter Tremayne’s (sp?) Fidelma mysteries, set in Ireland in the 600’s. She’s a nun and a detective/lawyer sort of person. The setting and character development isn’t quite as well done as Cadfael, but the author is a history scholar, and it does bring some of the history alive. I read the short stories and the first book alongside Cahill’s How the Irish Saved Civilization. It was a fortuitous pairing.

  2. Pingback: Pseudo-Polymath » Blog Archive » Morning Highlights

  3. I like Marie Killilea’s books, Tomie dePaola’s books, Rumer Godden’s books, The Hawk and the Dove, anything by G.K. Chesterton, Les Miserables, everything by Flannery O’Connor, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, The Cloister and the Hearth, everything by Evelyn Waugh, Hilda van Stockum’s books – particularly the Mitchells trilogy and the Cottage at Bantry Bay trilogy, books by Willa Cather, Walker Percy’s books, All Quiet on the Western Front, poems by Gerard Manley Hopkins and by Allen Tate.

    I’ve never read In This House of Brede, but it’s on the bookshelf. Maybe I should go ahead and add it to the summer reading stack….

  4. I’m so glad you’re back. I was raised in the Catholic tradition before attending the evangelical church I attend today. Sometimes I miss the reverence and humility of Catholicism. Thank you for the reading suggestions. Perhaps I’ll revisit past traditions.

  5. My bloggy friend MamaT recommends many of the books you have posted. She also loves a writter named Jon Hassler. I have read two of his books; Staggerford and The Staggerford Flood. They were excellent.

  6. Oh and Peter Kreeft is an amazing Catholic “apologist”.

    I have read many quotes by him and a few of his books too.

    Julie D. at Happy Catholic highly recommends him.

    (I am not Catholic, but my husband is…I am a Catholic sympathizer :o)

  7. I agree that Peter Kreeft is very good. I also enjoyed listening to a set of tapes by Scott and Kimberley Hahn, although I’ve not read any of their books.

  8. Pingback: Cadmusings » Blog Archive » Christian Carnival CXXVIII

  9. Hi, Sherry. I am Lutheran, but have enjoyed the same Catholic flavor of certain books. (Many Lutherans are aesthetically Catholic, even if we argue like Protestants.)

    My favorite is Brideshead Revisited by Evelyn Waugh. That book is wonderful on many counts. Oxford in the early twentieth century. Upper class British life. How the black sheep members of the family who consider themselves semi-pagans are still haunted by their faith. This is education by full immersion.

  10. I’ve read Shoes of the Fisherman–it was fascinating, because it was written before JP2 and was prophetic in many ways! The main character, the pope, is very appealing in his humility.

    Similar to the Brother Cadfael series and I think just as good, or very nearly so, are the Dame Frevisse novels by Margaret Frazer.

    Death Comes to the Archbishop is another Catholic classic that comes to mind. A slowpaced but beautiful story about a Catholic priest in the old Southwest.

  11. When my older children were younger and even before they were ready for the whole story, I read the part of Les Miserables with the bishop out loud to them. It’s one of my favorite passages in any book. My 14 yo daughter just read the whole book (Unabridged. I can’t stand abridged books, and neither can she.).

    I also like Graham Greene, and just ordered Monsignor Quixote (since I’ve read it 3 or 4 times).

  12. Pingback: CadmusSorrell.com | Christian Carnival CXXVIII

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *